[Home]Dubious historical resources/Talk

HomePage | Dubious historical resources | Recent Changes | Preferences | Random Page

Showing revision 6
Please feel free to add to this collection... sjc
WHAT a nice idea, Steve. I've already added one. I hope you've linked it to the history homepage! --MichaelTinkler

Yes, it was on my list, and also to the History standards page. sjc


"Dubious historical resources": Speaking as a layperson here ... Almost anything related to King Arthur. Almost anything related to history of Asian martial arts; ninja?, Shaolin Temple, etc., etc.

Yes, I think that probably goes without saying. But some of the Arthurian stuff, for example, if handled correctly can be very revealing of the mores of the times as "unwitting testimony" e.g. [Gawain and the Green Knight]? says quite a lot about mediaeval attitudes towards sin and guilt. What I think we're really trying to get at here, though, is the stuff which some historians tend to cite without comment and which (usually) is purported to be primary source material but is usually (at best) second hand, i.e. stuff masqueraded as authoratitive which isn't. sjc


tacitus! why didn't I think of that, since we kept writing and rewriting qualifiers on every use of him! --MichaelTinkler

HomePage | Dubious historical resources | Recent Changes | Preferences | Random Page
This page is read-only | View other revisions | View current revision
Edited November 16, 2001 5:30 pm by 66.153.24.xxx (diff)
Search: