[Home]Major cases of genocide and democide/Talk

HomePage | Major cases of genocide and democide | Recent Changes | Preferences

Showing revision 3
Reasoning under merging:
It is not true that every instance of a genocide is a democide! Mass sterilizations or removal of children can constitute genocide, but these are not democide because they don't involve any killings. Sure, the lists will overlap a fair bit, but they are quite distinct concepts. I think that having a list with both will only add to the common misunderstanding that genocides only involve killing, or that all killings are genocides.
I agree that distinct notions should be treated on separate pages. "Democide" refers to killing by government (the nature of the perpetrator is the basis for deciding whether or not something is a democide). "Genocide" refers to killing based on ethnicity (the nature of the victims is the basis here). I suspect that some genocides were perpetrated by groups without being ordered by governmental bodies, so wouldn't qualify as democides. Events should be classified carefully.

HomePage | Major cases of genocide and democide | Recent Changes | Preferences
This page is read-only | View other revisions | View current revision
Edited November 2, 2001 8:40 pm by Seb (diff)
Search: