HomePage | RecentChanges | Preferences

<The following is a portion of LarrysText, wikified; further development encouraged>

A good StatE? is one that does (well) whatever GovernmenT?s should do, and it does nothing else. This platitude makes it more pressing that we try to find out what governments should do--what their proper functions are, and are not.

We might be tempted to say, as nearly everyone can agree, that the purpose of the state is to protect RightS? and to preserve JusticE?. But this raises more questions than it answers. Which and whose rights? What sort of justice? There are, after all, many different conceptions of what rights we have, and what justice consists of.

It is on those questions that one can find the differences between ConservatisM?, WelfareStateLiberalism?, LibertarianisM, SocialisM, and FascisM?. There are a handful of anarchists (see AnarchisM) among the Socialists (see TraditionalAnarchism) and the Libertarians (see AnarchoCapitalism). But everyone else agrees that the existence of some kind of government is morally justified. What they disagree about is what government should do.

One fairly useful way to conceive of the differences between these different views is as how much they want government to do. For a stark and timely contrast, consider two of these views: Libertarianism, which wants the state to do only a few things, and Socialism, which wants the state to do a lot of things. LibertarianisM, in political theory, is the view that the function of the state is only to keep people from harming each other. In other words, an individual should be free to do anything they want, so long as they do not infringe upon the rights of others to do what they want. The government's role is to protect those rights. SocialisM, nearly on the other end of a continuum, is the view that the state is responsible for an equitable distribution of wealth and for controlling the means of production and distribution of resources in an economy.

As you can see, once we have given some justification for the existence of the state at all, we are faced with the question of what governments are morally justified in doing, which is another way of saying what their purposes or functions should be. This turns to be one of the most important questions that can be asked.


HomePage | RecentChanges | Preferences
This page is read-only | View other revisions
Last edited February 16, 2001 5:00 am by LarrySanger (diff)