[Home]Judeo-Christian tradition

HomePage | Recent Changes | Preferences

Showing revision 22
The term Judeo-Christian tradition (also spelt Judaeo-Christian tradition) is a term used to describe the concepts and values that are shared between Christianity and Judaism. It is frequently used in American political discourse, in an attempt to create a non-denominational American Christian religious consenus that does not appear anti-semitic by excluding Judaism.

The phrase "Judeo-Christian" implies somewhat more commality than actually exists. The reality is more nuanced; Judaism and Christianity have both many areas of agreement, as well as sharply defined ethical and religious systems that are in some areas polar opposites. Given the differences, many religious Jews and Christians find the phrase "Judeo-Christian tradition" to be an oxymoron. The phrase "Judeo-Christian" can also be criticised for excluding Islam. On the other hand, the phrase is about a common bible and history. Islam itself rejects the entire Bible as an inspired work, and instead holds only the Quran to be the true word of God.

Recently obver 50 rabbis from the non-Orthodox branches of Judaism signed a document called Dabru Emet ("Speak the Truth") that has since been used in Jewish education programs across the US. Some Modern Orthodox rabbis have made statements in agreement with this document as well, but have not signed. This is because Orthodox Judaism is more strict than the other denominations in regards to the Jewish religious prohibition against inter-religion theological dialogue. (In the past such dialogues were forced, and had as their sole motive the conversion of Jews to other faiths.)

While affirming that there are differences between these two religions, the purpose of Dabru Emet is to point out the common ground between these two religions. It is not an official document of any of the Jewish denominations per se, but it is representative of what many religious Jews (both rabbis and laypeople) feel. [[Dabru Emet]]

Comparing and Contrasting Judaism and Christianity

God

Both Jews and Christians believe in the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, the God of the Tanach (Old Testament, Hebrew Bible), the creator of the universe. However, Christianity posits a trinity, in which the Godhead possess three distinct persons; In that three there are one and in that one there are three. Judaism sees God as a strict unity, and views trinitarianism as both incomprehensible and a violation of the Bible's statement that God is one.

Messiah

Both Jews and Christians believe that a descendent of King David will one day appear to restore the Kingdom of [[Israel], and who will usher in a messianic era of peace. Jews refer to this person as a moshiach, which is usually translated as "messiah". Christians also believe in a messiah, but they give a very different definition to this term. Readers should read the Wikipedia entries on Jewish eschatology, messiah, and Jesus Christ to learn about the significant differences between these two concepts.

Faith vs. Good deeds

Judaism teachs that the purpose of the Torah is to show that deeds, actual acts undertaken by a person, are considered by God to be more imporant than one's beliefs. Christianity teaches that the purpose of Jesus's message in the [[New Testament] is to show that beliefs (such as belief in Jesus as the son of God) held by a person are considered by God to be more important than one's actions.

Salvation/Attaining an afterlife

Both Jews and Chrisitians believe that there will be some sort of afterlife. Christianity generally posits that one can be saved through the acceptance of Jesus as a saviour, although many variants of Christianity do teach that salvation is available to followers of other faiths as well. In general, though, has historically tended to place greater emphasis on faith than actions. Judaism holds the polar opposite view and claims that whatever salvation may exist is found only through ethical action; beliefs play no role.

Abortion

Both Jews and Christians regard pregnancy as a gift from God, and hold children to be miracles. However, most branches of Christianity have historically held abortion to be murder. Judaism claims that the fetus is not yet a full human being, and thus is not murder, and therefore abortion - in restricted circumstances - has always been legal under Jewish law. Judaism prefers that such abortions, when necessary, take place before the first 40 days.

The Bible

Jews and Christians seek authority from the some of the same basic books, but they conceive of these books in significanlty different ways. Jews call their Bible the Tanach, a Hebrew acronym for the three sections of their scriptures: Torah (the five books of Moses), Nevi'im (the Prophets), and Ketuvim (Writings). Jews traditionally believe that these written works are accompanied by an oral tradition which was revealed to Moses at Sinai and passed down through generations (and eventually written down in the Talmud (see below)). Jews believe that these written and (formerly) oral traditions together embody a living covenant between them and God.

Christians reject this view: they reject the oral tradition, and they reject the Jewish order of sacred texts (and some Christian traditions have included in their "Old Testament" books that are not included in the Jewish canon). Most importantly, they reject the covenant with God embodied in these traditions as obsolete, and thus refer to their canon of Hebrew books as the "Old Testament." Christians believe that God has established a new covenant with people, and that this new covenant is established in an additional set of books collectively called the "New Testament."

Jews do not accept the New Testament (nor do they accept the charactarization of their sacred texts as an "Old" Testament), although they do accept as sacred certain texts that are not included in the Tanach which were written at a much later date; especially the Mishna, which was compiled around 200 C.E., and a Babylonian and a Jerusalem Gemarim, which were edited around 500 C.E. Many Jews believe that these texts, together called the Babylonian and Jerusalem Talmuds, contain the Oral Law revealed to Moses at Mt. Sinai.

Dealing with violence and pacifism

Jews and Christians accept as valid and binding the moral principles taught in the Torah. There is a great deal of overlap between the ethical systems of these two faiths. Nonetheless, there are some highly significant doctrinal differences.

Judaism has a great many teachings about peace and compromise, and its teachings make physical violence the last possible option. Nonetheless, the Talmud teaches that "If someone comes with the intention to murder you, then one is obligated to kill in self-defense". The clear implication that to do anything less would be tantamount to suicide (which Jewish law forbids) and it would also be considered helping a murderer kill someone. The tension between the laws dealing with peace, and the obligation to self-defense, has led to a set of Jewish teachings that may be described as tactical-pacifism. This is the avoidance of force and violence whenever possible, but the use of it when necessary to save the lives of one's-self and one's people.

The New Testament teaches that if someone comes to harm you, then one must turn the other cheek. This has led many Christians to develop a theology of pacifism, the avoidance of force and violence at all times. In practice, this has often not been followed (i.e. the many crusades, pogroms in Russia, Martin Luther's exhortions to burn down synagogues with Jews still in them) when applied towards gentiles; pacifism in practice is most often applied towards inter-Christian disputes.

/Talk


HomePage | Recent Changes | Preferences
This page is read-only | View other revisions | View current revision
Edited December 17, 2001 6:21 am by Slrubenstein (diff)
Search: