[Home]Operation Barbarossa/Talk

HomePage | Operation Barbarossa | Recent Changes | Preferences

Before Barbarossa, the Germans and the Russians were allies, having signed an unexpected treaty shortly before the German invasion of Poland.

This wasn't anyting like "unexpected" and it wasn't German but German and Soviet invasion. --Taw


Right at the beginning of the article it needs to be stated, that Germany was aware of Soviet Union's plan to attack Germany. When Hitler found that out, he right away took the offensive and cought the Soviet Army in offensive position, therefore surprised them. Soviet Union had appr 30,000 tanks , Germany 6 or 9,000?, something like that.

Viktor Suworow , (book Ice-Breaker) and book "Der Tag M" (M=Mobilizing Day) proved that the Soviet Army under Stalin was ready to attack. Suworow recently inspected many documents. He was trained in Soviet Army at Suworow Officer School in Kaliningrad and at Officer College Kiev.

Further down in the article it needs to be stated , that the main reason, for bogging down the German army, was weather, the rains and early winter . H. Jonat


I think it needs to be pointed out that the Germans were bogged down by the weather at Moscow mainly because they first took a detour southward earlier in the campaign. Hitler ordered Army Group Center southward to conquer the Ukraine in a pincer operation instead of taking Moscow earlier in the campaign. I believe that several of Hitler's generals, including Guderian, argued against this. By the time they returned towards the push to Moscow, the muds and then the snows had stopped the advance. -- Egern


BBC article you gave (http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/war/wwtwo/countdown/countdown_1.shtml) contains at least one important mistake - in April 1939 Inagresion Pact between Germany and Poland was cancelled by Germans, so no way could Hitler be "bound by an agreement he signed with Poland in January 1934". --Taw

HomePage | Operation Barbarossa | Recent Changes | Preferences
This page is read-only | View other revisions
Last edited December 7, 2001 2:48 am by Taw (diff)
Search: