- Such a discovery would cause problems for worldviews that presume the uniqueness of human beings and the universal importance of human events, especially certain religious viewpoints.
For example? --
LMS
For example,
Christianity. Christianity (at least in some of its forms) presumes a certain uniqueness for human beings, and that human history is of unique importance in the grand schemes of things: that God became incarnate in a human being is one of its beliefs. I suspect that problems would arise if other life forms existed: why humans? why didn't God become incarnate in any other intelligent lifeforms? Now Christianity (even of the more traditional sort I am referring to here) could no doubt survive the discovery of alien life, but it would make it seem less likely -- that God chose some particular lifeform for events of grand cosmic import seems much more believable when there is only one lifeform for him to choose from. --
Simon J Kissane
I was asking for a definite example be added to
extraterrestrial life. Frankly, although I'm about as nonreligious as they come, I'm skeptical of the claim.
What events of grand cosmic import (as opposed to grand
Earthly import) does Christianity allege? If Jesus is divine, why couldn't he be poking around on other planets, spreading the gospel (that would explain why he's been gone for lo these 2,000 years)? See, I just wanted the claim, which strikes me as prejudiced, given some definite proof. Otherwise, it should be stricken. --
LMS
Christianity as a whole may not assert these things, but some branches of it do, and I have both talked to people and seen programs which asert that Christianity (meaning their version) does not allow for extraterrestrial life. So, if Christ comes but twice, he can't be off saving people on other worlds, if man is God's image then nothing else could conceivably possess the faculty of reason, and while I'm not sure where the uniqueness of earthly life is argued from I can tell you that it sometimes is. How widespread such conclusions are, though, I do not know.
I don't see it as particularly prejudiced. But since it seems to be controversial, I'm going to delete it anyway. --
Simon J Kissane
"If extraterrestrial life was discovered to exist, it would have profound implications for all human thought, especially if the life was intelligent."
This seems non-encyclopedic. It is a sweeping assertion, and one that I rather doubt. - TS
---
Should we mention the Martian meteorite and the Viking experiments? Robert Merkel
![[Home]](wikipedia.png)